We Buy Pokemon Cards!

 

Pokémon Collection Buying Policy

At The Eternal Forge, we proudly offer a trusted space for Pokémon collectors to sell their valued cards and products. To ensure a fair and straightforward experience, please review our in-person buying policy below.

📦 Accepted Items

We are open to buying:

  • Singles (non-bulk)
  • Sealed Products (booster boxes, tins, packs, etc.)
  • Graded Slabs (from PSA, CGC, BGS, etc.)

💰 Pricing Guide

  • We use TCGPlayer Market Price and eBay Last Sold listings as our primary pricing sources.
  • Final Offers are based on the condition of each item (e.g., Near Mint, Lightly Played, Damaged, etc.)
  • Damaged or heavily played items may receive lower offers or be declined.
  • Our standard payout rates:
    • 70% of market value in cash
    • 80% of market value in store credit

💡 Any unused store credit will be issued to you on a digital gift card for future use at The Eternal Forge.

How to Sell Your Pokémon Collection

  • Walk In Anytime
    • No appointments are needed.
    • Simply bring your collection to our store during business hours.
    • This is an in-person only process — we do not accept shipped collections.
  • On-the-Spot Evaluation
    • Our team will review your collection, assess the condition of your items, and make you a fair offer using current market data.
  • Choose Your Payment Method
    • If you accept our offer, you may choose:
      • Cash (70% of value) — paid via PayPal Friends & Family or Cashapp
      • Store Credit (80% of value) — available for immediate use or issued on a digital gift card if unused

 

 

Got questions before your visit? Feel free to reach out using the form below. We’re excited to see your collection!